Origin: Isle of Islay (Scotland)
Type: Single Malt Scotch Whisky
Ageing casks: Ex-Bourbon
Added coloring: Yes
Average price: € 36.00
Official website: www.malts.com
Like the Lagavulin 16 reviewed in these pages, another of the whiskies that is undoubtedly best known is the 12-year-old Caol Ila. Equally widespread in large (and small) retailers, available at a more than affordable price, and always in the family of peated whiskies from that friendly and lively little Scottish island, which from the list of distilleries it hosts almost seems to trip over each other…
Some might think that two spirits coming from the same area and with similar characteristics (even in terms of alcohol content) are therefore the same.
But no, because the beauty (and charm) of whisky lies precisely in its ability to stand out clearly, thanks to the “displacement” of individual details, even if only geographical, which may appear superficial on paper but which make all the difference.
For example, compared to the Lagavulin 16, poured into the glass we already find a clearer colour (although there is always our friend caramel to ‘pollute’ things), which unfortunately the dark bottle doesn’t allow to appreciate.
The Islay provenance can be felt in the brackish scents that accompany the peat, together with citrus and fresh notes which, if the glass is left to air for some time, also bring out a certain spiciness.
The palate reflects what was perceived on the nose, with the smokiness of the peat again (scents that clearly recall the places of origin of this distillate), together with pepper and citrus. The oceanic salinity is always present, well integrated into the whole, without ever overwhelming the colours of the whisky.
Smoke and spices remain in the mouth after emptying (calmly) the glass, in which the scent remains present for as long as on the palate.
Close and yet far from its island cousin, I personally like it just a little less, it’s really hard to put into words why. Perhaps I find the Lagavulin 16 more elegant on the whole, more structured.
But have at it, especially at this price…
Reviews of Caol Ila whisky in the blog:
A&G Rare Cask Selection Caol Ila 10yo
Cadenhead’s Caol Ila 30yo
Caol Ila 18yo
Caol Ila 18yo Unpeated 2017
Caol Ila Distillers Edition 2018
Caol Ila Moch
Caol Ila Natural Cask Strength
Càrn Mòr Vertical
Dramfool Cola Ali 4
Dramfool Cola Ali 5
Golden Drops Caol Ila 8yo
Gordon&MacPhail Reserve Caol Ila 2008
Morisco Spirits Caol Ila 11yo
Signatory Caol Ila 1994 Port Wood Finish
The Islay Star 11yo
Valinch & Mallet Caol Ila 11yo
Wilson & Morgan Caol Ila 2008-2020 Quercus Alba
One More Dram