
Origin: Isle of Islay (Scotland)
Type: Single Malt Scotch Whisky
Strength: 49.9%ABV
Ageing casks: Ex-Bourbon
Chillfiltered: No
Additional coloring: No
Owner: Kilchoman
Average price: € 250.00
Official website: kilchomandistillery.com
2025 marked the twentieth anniversary of the Islay distillery, which continued the celebrations the following year with a series designed to highlight the family character of this farm distillery.
Four bottlings released in July 2026 in the Family Collection series (First Edition, suggesting there will be further releases), ranging from eleven to this twenty-year-old, the oldest whisky they have produced so far, with the 14-year-old bottle in the Rockside version, meaning it is made entirely from barley grown on their own farm.
Peated malt at 50ppm from Port Ellen, reduced strength, fully matured in ex-bourbon casks.
Tasting Notes
Despite the (formally) high peat level, on the nose it reveals a sweet and delicate smoke, both vegetal and iodine-tinged, intertwined with notes of fruit (pineapple, tinned peaches, apple, ripe pear, apricot, blond orange, mango), pastry (panna cotta, tarte tatin, lemon cream) and cashews. A second layer then emerges, highlighting coastal and saline aspects, between brine, grilled scallops and soy sauce, with a hint of Taggiasca olives and slightly burnt shortcrust pastry. Calm in character, yet substantial.
On the palate, it becomes slightly sharper, bringing out spices (black pepper, ginger), more pronounced citrus (lime, orange), and an unexpected balsamic, mentholated profile, not aggressive but clearly present. The smoke gains in pitch and body, while bitter and herbal notes grow, between licorice root, bergamot tea, rhubarb, and tobacco leaves. Fruit and pastry move into the background, more evident on the finish together with the savory profile, which takes on hints of sea and grilled shellfish.
Finish long, with lingering bitter notes punctuated by fruit, pastry, and spices, leading to a clear predominance of vegetal and coastal smoke.
Conclusions: I still believe that Kilchoman whisky performs best with shorter maturations; these twenty years seem to take away more than they add, sacrificing the distillery’s strong personality on the altar of elegance. A full and satisfying dram, to be clear, but it seems to lack drive.
Vote: 87/100
